A bill on transfer of religious communities to another jurisdiction presented in Parliament

1 March 2016, 09:34 | Legislation | 3 |   | Code for Blog |  | 

Kyiv_Ukraine_irs.in.ua-w.jpgDraft amendments to the Law of Ukraine "On freedom of conscience and religious organizations" relating to the change of affiliation with religious centers by religious communities were brought in the Ukrainian Parliament.


The initiators of the bill No. 4128 were by Victor Yelenskyy, Svitlana Voitsekhovska, Pavlo Kyshkar and four more MPs, the Institute of Religious Freedom reports.


According to the authors, the bill is designed “to enforce the rights of members of religious communities to informed choice and free and unimpeded change of affiliation with religious centers for satisfying their religious needs and dignified expression of religious feelings.” The proposed changes are intended to “regulate the procedure of changing affiliation of the religious communities and religious centers (leadership) operating in Ukraine and abroad.”


This initiative has provoked criticism of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church (Moscow Patriarchate), whose representative expressed concern about using these changes to simplify the transfer of churches in the course of transitions of Orthodox communities from the jurisdiction of the Moscow Patriarchate to that of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church Kyiv Patriarchate.


“In practice, it will look as follows - the general meeting of faithful (parish meeting) will be attended by other persons who do not belong to the religious community, but nevertheless will have the right to vote and will be entitled to adopt or amend the statute of the religious community,” said Rev Alexander Bakhov, head of the UOC Synodal Legal Department.


On the other hand, according to IRS experts, difficulties may arise in the activities of religious communities, the statutes of which stipulate fixed membership, particularly in Protestant (evangelical) churches or which delegate the right to amend the statute to other governing bodies - the Parish Council, the Council of Elders, a brotherhood council.


“As an example, the decision of a religious community to change denomination will not be adopted by the general meeting of its members, but by third persons, who used to visit public service or visited it on occasion. The result may be a situation where the registration authorities will have to decide whether to take note of the decision taken in accordance with the Statute of the registered religious community or the one adopted in accordance with legislative amendments. Courts could face a similar problem,” said lawyer Maksym Vasin, Executive Director of the Institute for Religious Freedom, a member of the Expert Council of the Ministry of Culture of Ukraine.


As the IRS notes, the ruling of the European Court of Human Rights in the case “St. Michael Parish v. Ukraine” (Application No. 77703/01) states:


“The Court recalls that religious groups have the right to determine at their discretion the manner in which they will accept the new and exclude the existing members. The internal structure of religious organizations and rules governing its membership should be seen as the way in which such organizations may express their views and observe their religious traditions. The Court indicates that the right to freedom of religion excludes any powers of the state to assess the legitimacy of the ways of expressing religious beliefs.”


Currently, bill No. 4128 is pending consideration of the Parliamentary Committee on Culture and Spirituality.

Система Orphus
3comments count


add comments 
  • Кропива | 1 March 2016, 15:43
    comment comment

    то ж для чого було вносити цей проект змін? він не є актуальним, він протирічить рішенню Європейського Суду, він викличе нову хвилю обурень та непорозумінь. немає чим зайнятися у країні?

  • 13moiseev | 1 March 2016, 14:15
    comment comment

    Весь час перечитував минулий закон про Церкву "http://zakon2.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/987-12" - все чітко позначене та оформлене що до вподобань кожного. А тепер що, якщо я вирішу передати одну церку чи будівлю іншій кофесії мені варто зібрати підписи та бажаючих?? Це як з Св.Софією?

  • 13moiseev | 1 March 2016, 11:46
    comment comment

    Гряде буря, понаприймають же.

Сan leave comments only to registered visitors Еnter

Last comments

  • bopa | 8 June 2020, 11:43

    То перераховані факти ви називаєте "фантазиями и ночными кошмарами"? Чому викладену інформацію ви "Очередная статья нижайшего интеллектуального уровня"? У вас

  • Slava43 | 4 June 2020, 13:46

    Це жодна агітація. На Буковині казали :»Мойше герехт, Сури герехт».

  • Slava43 | 4 June 2020, 13:39

    За часів союза, УПЦ підлягала моіковському патріярхату, примусово. Від незалежності УПЦ старалась отримати незалежність від Москви. Тепер, коли Україна має ТОМОС та незалежність то Лавру потрібно

  • Стефан | 2 June 2020, 15:54

    Последние события показали глубокий кризис РПЦ МП, где только отдельные редкие священнослужители твёрдо исповедуют Православную Веру, как схиигумен отец Сергий Романов, которого сейчас травят

  • Рокитне | 2 June 2020, 12:34

    Це добре було б.

Most Popular Articles month